Are there any Drawbacks or Limitations to using a Berkey Water Filter?

Are there any Drawbacks or Limitations to using a Berkey Water Filter?

By Dan DeBaun

Berkey Water filters are capable of removing more than 200 common drinking water contaminants and are pretty powerful as home water filter systems go. Black Berkey filter elements, the filter media that essentially forms the heart of a Berkey system, employs a combination of different filtration technologies consisting of micropores that allow water to pass through but trap contaminants, as well as activated carbon and other innovative materials which have adsorption and ion exchange properties that draw viruses and other contaminants to the media. It's clear that Berkey Water Filters have a lot to offer, but there are some limitations.

Higher Price Tag

One drawback that often puts people off buying a Berkey is the high upfront cost of purchasing a Berkey system compared to other cheaper water filters available on the market. However, while the Berkey is not a cheap system, you need to consider the outlay as an investment in your health and that of your family. You also need to compare the long-term running costs of each system.

Cheaper filters typically use disposable filter cartridges that have to be replaced regularly. The Berkey, on the other hand, is very economical over the long-term as a set of two filter elements will filter approximately 6000 gallons of water before needing to be replaced. So even while the initial purchase cost may be high, the Berkey ends up saving you quite a lot of money in the long run.

Needs to be Filled Regularly

As the Berkey is a free-standing countertop system that is not attached to a faucet or fitted in-line, you will need to manually fill it up to keep enjoying a steady supply of filtered water. This really isn't a tedious chore, but one does need to remember to do so regularly to ensure filtered water is available on tap.

Slow Filtration Rate

A common complaint with gravity filters, including the Berkey, is the time it takes for water to filter through to the storage chamber. Gravity filters rely on gravity rather than water pressure to draw water through the filter elements, which is much slower than filtration systems that work on water pressure. However, there are some benefits to this. Since the contaminants are not forced through the filter elements but remain in contact with the filter elements for longer, the filters are more effective at removing them. This results in higher quality water.

If you have limited patience to wait for water to trickle through, just refill our system before bed, and ensure it is kept topped up as you use it. You can also speed up the filtration process by adding additional filter elements if your system allows.

Can Take up Counter Space

Being a countertop gravity water filter means that it has to sit on your kitchen counter. If you have limited space in your kitchen, this could be a problem. Also, if you have kitchen cabinets above your countertops you may limited to what size Berkey you can fit in the space between. Some of the larger Berkey systems may be too tall to fit under kitchen cabinets, so bear that in mind when choosing your system.

Spigot Needs to Hang Over Counter

In order to be able put a glass under the spout of a Berkey, it needs to hang over the edge of the kitchen counter. This may result in a lot of wasted counter space behind the filter. If this is a problem, you can purchase a stand for your Berkey, which will elevate it, making it more accessible from the counter.

While the pros of owning a Berkey far outweigh the cons, understanding what the limitations and drawbacks are can help guide your with your purchasing decision and help you select a system that best meets your needs.

Dan DeBaun

Dan DeBaun

Dan DeBaun is the owner and operator of Big Berkey Water Filters. Prior to Berkey, Dan was an asset manager for a major telecommunications company. He graduated from Rutgers with an undergraduate degree in industrial engineering, followed by an MBA in finance from Rutgers as well. Dan enjoys biohacking, exercising, meditation, beach life, and spending time with family and friends.

~ The Owner of Big Berkey Water Filters

Back to blog
  • Avatar of Seilor Seilor 2025-04-19 17:14:14

    Hi. We have been using our Berkey water filter since the Coronavirus outbreak with no complaints. However, in the last month we noticed RUST forming in the underside of the lid. What do I do? Thank you.

  • Avatar of Dan DeBaun Dan DeBaun 2025-04-21 13:28:54

    Hi Seilor -

    Yes, rust can happen for some customers depending on their water source; typically those who have higher sodium levels in their water. However, this can be cleaned and removed. Please see the end of this article for tips on cleaning this rust from you Berkey system.

    https://www.bigberkeywaterfilters.com/blog/how-to-clean-berkey-systems

    Thanks
    Dan

  • Avatar of Rose andrews Rose andrews 2025-04-06 15:49:54

    I want to buy replacement black filters for my Berkey but Berkey says they are out of stock. It’s been a really long time. Where can I buy them.

  • Avatar of Dan DeBaun Dan DeBaun 2025-04-08 14:35:17

    Hi Rose -

    They are still unavailable while we sue the EPA. They are only available with new systems as this is still permissible. Any black berkey replacements being sold are most likely counterfeits, especially on sites like Amazon, Walmart or Ebay, so buyer beware.

    Until this is resolved and as a stop-gap filter, we have the newly approved Ultra Serasyl Ceramic filters available as a replacement option. They are similar in performance and approx half the price. They just need to be replaced more often (approx once per year).

    https://www.bigberkeywaterfilters.com/replacement-filters.html

    Thanks
    Dan

  • Avatar of Bret Souza Bret Souza 2024-04-01 13:29:00

    First...I love my Berkey.

    Second, I am short on patience, but when I need to fill my Berkey, it really doesn't take all that long and I remind myself how much I appreciate what it is doing for me and I do it either before bed or early enough to not need it yet.

    Last, as far as taking up space and the spigot hanging over...I purchased a wooden plant stand that is the type that looks like dowels in a x, adjustable to the size of planter to be placed in it and I love it! I can even use the space under it, where I just have a cute little dish with a plant, placed just where the spigot may drip (sometimes I don't get it tight enough). My Berkey is probably the best thing I have ever purchased.

  • Avatar of Shirley Shirley 2023-09-05 18:43:11

    How can I tell when my black filters and fluoride filters need changing. I purchased my system around 2017ish but did not prime and use the system right away. The water that's filtered still tastes good and it is clear. Sometimes when I clean the filters water is filtered out slowly. It other times there's a steady flow of water filtered. I am really pleased with this system.

  • Avatar of Dan DeBaun Dan DeBaun 2023-09-06 17:54:21

    Hi Shirley -

    The fluoride filters need to be replaced once a year or 1000 gallons, whichever comes first, so these should be replaced. The black berkeys are good for appox 6000 gallons, and one can perform a red food coloring test on them at any time to verify that they are working to design specs.

    Thanks
    Dan

  • Avatar of Ron Ron 2023-05-07 12:53:02

    In what way are you an authorized Berkley dealer? You are not on their list of dealers. You appear to be an Amazon affiliate. That does not make you sellable to be an authorized dealer, Amazon is.

  • Avatar of Dan DeBaun Dan DeBaun 2023-05-08 23:39:55

    Hi Ron -

    We are the largest dealer for the manufacturer and we do not sell on Amazon We also have an authorized dealer logo on the bottom of the webpage. The manufacturer at berkeywater.com can also be contacted if you would like additional confirmation.

    Thanks
    Dan