Berkey Home Water Filters - Higher Quality for Less Money

By Dan DeBaun

The general public is slowly beginning to understand that our water supply has been compromised. Whether it be our well water that is being affected by general pollution, or our municipal water that is being heavily treated with disinfectants, our water is not as pure and pristine as we would hope. In response, much of the population has turned to bottled water and home water filters. Unfortunately, bottled water adds to pollution, it can get expensive, and in some cases is simply municipal water that's been bottled in a city like Atlanta. When it comes to home water filters, all water filter systems are not created equal. Many of the most popular water filters on the market remove or reduce some chemicals and contaminants, but leave gaping holes for other contaminants to pass through to our drinking glass. As I mentioned in my last home water filter post, I will be evaluating many of the other water filter solutions on the market over the next couple months, but would like to begin this journey comparing the berkey water filter against the models; Aquasana, Pur, and Brita. We'll call them the big three.

The High Quality of the Black Berkey Filter

It seems nowadays health is a topic of conversation on everybody's mind. The nutritional supplement and organic foods markets continue to grow by double digits year over year and is a testament to the customer's search for higher quality and better health. Water filtration seems to be slightly behind this awareness curve and is most likely due in large part to the public just recently coming to terms with what's really happening with our water supply. Just turn on the TV or go out on the internet and you'll see some other type of contaminant or chemical that's now being found in our drinking water.

The big three of Pur, Aquasana, and Brita are decent at filtering out some of the more well known disinfectants such as chlorine, but they do so only at ranges between 96-99%. Comparably, berkey water filters remove chlorine to beyond detectable levels. The Berkey also reduces heavy metals such as aluminum and lead, removes pathogenic bacteria and E-coli, nitrates and nitrites, and radon. The other water filters fail to address these contaminants and instead pass them through to your drinking glass completely. Even when it comes to very dangerous VOC's and THM's, that have been shown to have correlations to increases in illnesses such as cancer, only Aquasana and Pur have some impact at the 98-99% level. Yet these levels are well below the reduction levels of the Berkey which reduces both VOC's and THM's to beyond detectable limits. Finally, it's important to note that one of the fastest growing water concerns of the public is the fluoridation, or the addition of fluoride, to our municipal water supplies. Again, none of the big three water filters address fluoride. Conversely, Berkey systems have an add-on filter option for the black berkey filter elements called the PF-2 filter that specifically targets both fluoride and arsenic to reduce it by over 99.75%.

Save Money When You Buy a Berkey Home Water Filter

I don't think there's anyone in the US or Canada that hasn't been impacted by the economic depression. It's been a tough couple years, and while wall street and the government talk about a recovery underway, many of us on main street simply don't see it. Every decision we make needs to be one that maximizes that value of our hard earned dollar. That leaves many of us spending our time trying to determine how to get the highest quality the for the least amount of money. When it comes to water filtration, if you start to do the math, Aquasana, Pur, and Brita are simply not the most cost effective. A one-time investment in a standard Berkey home water filter such as the Berkey Light or the Big Berkey will cost the consumer $209 or $250 respectively, and provide at least 5 years of high quality filtration. Comparably, the big three require many filter replacements across this 5 year period and result in a total cost ranging between $560 and $658. That's more than twice the cost for inferior water filtration. Even when the Berkey secondary fluoride filters are added on, the black berkey / PF-2 combination is still cheaper. (chart below) Addt'l details can be found at berkey home water filters comparison chart.

Model Big Berkey w/ 2 BB (Black Berkey Filters) Big Berkey w/ 2 CF (Ceramic Filters) PF-2 Fluoride and Arsenic Filters (For use w/ Black Berkey Filter PF-4 Fluoride and Arsenic Filters (For use with Ceramic Filters) Aquasana Countertop (AQ-4000) Pur 3 Stage Faucet Filter (FM9700) Brita Faucet Filter w/ advanced features Brita Pitcher Filter
1st Yr Cost 2 $250 $250 $55 $95 $170 $190 $170 $177
2nd Yr Cost $0 $0 $55 $95 $78 $156 $156 $160
3rd Yr Cost $0 $0 $0 $95 $156 $156 $156 $160
4th Yr Cost $0 $0 $55 $95 $156 $156 $156 $160
5th Yr Cost $0 $0 $55 $95 $156 $156 $156 $160
5 Year Total Investment $250 $250 $220 $475 $560 $658 $638 $657

Making choices that affect the health of you and your family are some of the most important choices that you can ever make. Berkey water filters are considered one of the highest quality filtration systems on the market, and they'll save you money while providing you the healthy drinking water your family needs. To learn more about which water filter system will suit you best, please read this article on how to choose a berkey filter system.

Dan DeBaun

Dan DeBaun

Dan DeBaun is the owner and operator of Big Berkey Water Filters. Prior to Berkey, Dan was an asset manager for a major telecommunications company. He graduated from Rutgers with an undergraduate degree in industrial engineering, followed by an MBA in finance from Rutgers as well. Dan enjoys biohacking, exercising, meditation, beach life, and spending time with family and friends.

~ The Owner of Big Berkey Water Filters

Back to blog
  • Avatar of Scott Scott 2009-12-21 21:34:55

    Great article! I don't think many people think about shower (and bath) water either. Dr Oz recently made some great points about this on his show. See: http://www.doctoroz.com/videos/dont-drink-water .