Berkey vs Waterdrop: Which Gravity Filter Is Better?
Last updated: October 28, 2026
Share
Berkey and Waterdrop both offer gravity-fed stainless steel filtration systems at the same 2.25-gallon capacity, but they differ significantly in contaminant testing depth, public lab documentation, and price. Waterdrop's King Tank is less expensive upfront (about $150 with 2 carbon and 2 fluoride filters at Walmart). New Big Berkey and Royal Berkey systems come with Berkey Phoenix Elements or, while supplies last, Black Berkey Elements, both tested against 200+ contaminants by independent accredited third-party laboratories, with publicly downloadable lab reports. Buyers who prioritize published lab data and contaminant breadth will lean toward Berkey; buyers who prioritize a lower entry cost and a metal sight-glass spigot will find Waterdrop competitive.
Berkey is the better fit if you:
- Want downloadable third-party lab reports for 200+ contaminants
- Need documented PFAS reduction data (Phoenix: 7 compounds tested; Black Berkey: 9 compounds, PFOA reduced to below 2 ppt)
- Value a 25+ year brand track record with verified media coverage
- Plan to filter more than just chlorine and sediment
- Need multiple system sizes beyond 2.25 gallons
Waterdrop may be a better fit if you:
- Have a tighter upfront budget
- Primarily need chlorine, taste, and odor reduction
- Prefer a metal sight-glass spigot included as standard
- Only need a 1.5 or 2.25-gallon countertop system
Brand Background
Berkey is manufactured by New Millennium Concepts Ltd. (NMCL), which has been producing gravity filtration systems since the late 1990s. With more than 25 years in operation, NMCL has built an extensive dealer network and a documented testing history across multiple independent laboratories. BigBerkeyWaterFilters.com is the largest authorized Berkey dealer in the United States. New Big Berkey and Royal Berkey systems come with Berkey Phoenix Elements or, while supplies last, Black Berkey Elements. Both are tested by independent accredited third-party laboratories against 200+ contaminants. Berkey Phoenix Elements are also the replacement element and are certified to NSF/ANSI 42 and NSF/ANSI/CAN 372; Black Berkey Elements are tested to NSF/ANSI protocols but not certified.
Waterdrop is a China-based filtration brand founded in 2015 that has grown quickly in the U.S. market. The King Tank's manual says it is made in China. The company sells a broad product line including RO systems, pitcher filters, and gravity-fed countertop units. Its King Tank series is its primary gravity filter product, sold directly through Waterdropfilter.com and through Amazon. Waterdrop has explicitly noted that its products are not sourced by or affiliated with Berkey, though it does separately sell replacement filter cartridges marketed as compatible with Berkey systems. The two companies have no corporate relationship.
Quick Comparison: Berkey vs. Waterdrop King Tank
Scroll right to see full table.
| Feature | Berkey (Phoenix or Black Berkey Elements) | Waterdrop King Tank |
|---|---|---|
| System Capacity | 2.25 gal (Big Berkey) to 6 gal (Crown) | 2.25 gallons (King Tank); a 1.5 gallon model is also sold Fewer options |
| Filter Type | Phoenix: CTC-60 coconut shell carbon. Black Berkey: proprietary blend of several media types, including carbon; four filtration mechanisms (microfiltration, adsorption, absorption, ion exchange) | Natural coconut activated carbon (GAC) |
| Filter Lifespan | 5,500 gal/pair (Phoenix); 6,000 gal/pair (Black Berkey); no time limit | Up to 6,000 gal (carbon); maker advises replacing every 6 months |
| Testing / Certifications | Phoenix: certified to NSF/ANSI 42 and NSF/ANSI/CAN 372. Black Berkey: tested to NSF/ANSI protocols by independent accredited labs, not certified | Maker claims NSF/ANSI 42 and 372; manual lists IAPMO R&T certification to NSF/ANSI 372 (lead-free materials). No NSF/ANSI 42 listing found |
| Contaminants Tested | 200+, downloadable lab PDFs Berkey Edge | Chlorine (up to 98.95%) and heavy metals claimed; no named lab or downloadable report |
| PFAS Testing | Phoenix: 7 PFAS compounds at 99.8%+ initial reduction. Black Berkey: 9 compounds at >99.9% (PFOA tested directly, 8 by surrogate method), PFOA reduced to below 2 ppt Berkey Edge | No PFAS claim found on the King Tank product page |
| Public Lab Reports | Yes, downloadable PDFs from accredited labs Berkey Edge | Third-party testing referenced but full reports not publicly available |
| Filtration Speed | Phoenix: up to 4.2 gallons per hour per pair with a full upper chamber (max rating). Black Berkey: up to about 3.5 gallons per hour with a full upper chamber | Not published by the maker (one third-party reviewer measured about 4 gallons per hour) |
| Fluoride Reduction | PF-2 add-on filters required for reliable long-term fluoride reduction (up to 99.75%); compatible with both Black Berkey and Phoenix Elements ($103/pair, 1,000 gal) | Fluoride filter add-on ($56.99/pair, 1,000 gal); maker pages list 93% to 99.9% |
| Spigot | Plastic spigot (standard) | Metal sight glass spigot (standard) Waterdrop Edge |
| Cost Per Gallon | About 2 cents rated (Phoenix, $120/pair at 5,500 gal); no time limit, so the same at 1 gallon a day | About 1.3 cents rated ($78.99/pair at 6,000 gal); about 43 cents at 1 gallon a day if replaced every 6 months Depends on use |
| System Price | $267 (Big Berkey, 2 Phoenix); $367 (2 Black Berkey, while supplies last) | About $150 with 2 carbon and 2 fluoride filters (Walmart); $229.99 (2 carbon) or $259.99 (with 2 fluoride) on waterdropfilter.com; $199.99 for the fluoride kit with a promo code Waterdrop Edge |
| Verified Media Coverage | EWG, Food Network, CBS News, LA Times Berkey Edge | Not documented on media page |
| Brand History | 25+ years | Founded 2015 (11 years) |
Independent Testing and Certifications
Both brands cite NSF/ANSI 42 and 372, but the details differ. Berkey Phoenix Elements are certified to NSF/ANSI 42 and NSF/ANSI/CAN 372; Black Berkey Elements are tested to NSF/ANSI protocols but not certified. Waterdrop claims NSF/ANSI 42 and 372 for the King Tank; its manual lists IAPMO R&T certification to NSF/ANSI 372, and we found no NSF/ANSI 42 listing.
NSF/ANSI 42 applies to taste, odor, and chlorine reduction. It does not certify reduction of heavy metals, PFAS, pharmaceuticals, or other health-effects contaminants.
NSF/ANSI 372 addresses lead-free construction materials in plumbing components. It is a materials safety standard, not a performance standard for contaminant reduction.
Where the two diverge is in performance documentation beyond chlorine. Black Berkey Elements are tested by independent accredited third-party laboratories against 200+ contaminants. Black Berkey PFAS testing covers 9 compounds including PFOA, PFOS, PFNA, PFBS, and PFHxS, all reduced at >99.9%, with PFOA brought to below 2 ppt, under the EPA's enforceable 4 ppt MCL. Results are available as downloadable PDFs at BigBerkey Test Results. Berkey Phoenix Elements, which come on new Big and Royal systems and are the replacement element, were also tested against 200+ contaminants (7 PFAS compounds at 99.8%+ initial reduction) by NABL-accredited ISO/IEC 17025:2017 laboratories, with those results at the Phoenix Lab Results page.
Waterdrop states its King Tank is tested by a third-party laboratory for chlorine and heavy metals, but it does not name the lab. No downloadable performance test reports for the King Tank's contaminant reduction across a broad spectrum were found on Waterdrop's website. Buyers who want to verify specific contaminant reduction data should request documentation directly from Waterdrop before purchasing.
Contaminant Category Comparison
The table below compares documented contaminant reduction across major categories. Black Berkey data is sourced from independent lab reports available at BigBerkey Test Results. Waterdrop data reflects publicly available information from Waterdropfilter.com and product listings.
Scroll right to see full table.
| Contaminant Category | Black Berkey Elements | Waterdrop King Tank |
|---|---|---|
| PFAS / Forever Chemicals | 9 compounds tested (PFOA, PFOS, PFNA, PFDA, PFBS, PFHxS, PFHxA, PTFE, Fluorotelomer 8:2), all at >99.9%; PFOA reduced to below 2 ppt (below EPA 4 ppt MCL). Downloadable lab report available. Documented | No PFAS claim found on the King Tank product page, and no lab report published. |
| Heavy Metals | 20 metals tested including lead (>99.9%), mercury (>99.9%), arsenic (>99.9%), chromium VI (>99.8%), cadmium (>99.7%). Results consistent at both pH 6.5 and pH 8.5. Downloadable lab report available. Documented | Heavy metal reduction claimed. Third-party testing referenced but no downloadable lab report found on Waterdrop's website. |
| Pharmaceuticals and Emerging Contaminants | 17 compounds tested including ibuprofen, acetaminophen, BPA, caffeine, antibiotics, and hormones, all at >99.5%. Downloadable lab report available. Documented | No pharmaceutical reduction claims or testing data found publicly. |
| Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs) | 54 compounds tested including benzene, chloroform, toluene, TCE, MTBE, carbon tetrachloride, haloacetic acids, 99.60% to >99.99% reduction. Downloadable lab report available. Documented | No VOC reduction claims or testing data found publicly. |
| Pesticides and Herbicides | 40+ compounds tested including atrazine, chlordane, DDT, simazine, PCBs, glyphosate, >99.9% across most. Downloadable lab report available. Documented | No pesticide reduction claims or testing data found publicly. |
| Petroleum Contaminants | Gasoline, diesel, crude oil, kerosene, mineral spirits, refined oil, and MCHM, all at >99.9%. Downloadable lab report available. Documented | No petroleum contaminant claims or testing data found publicly. |
| Radiologicals | Gross alpha emitters at >98.7% (radium, uranium, plutonium, polonium); gross beta emitters at >95.3% (cesium-137, strontium-90, iodine-131). Downloadable lab report available. Documented | No radiological reduction claims or testing data found publicly. |
| Disinfectants (Chlorine and Chloramines) | Free chlorine >99.9%; chloramines >99.9%; total chlorine >87.5%. (Phoenix Elements are certified to NSF/ANSI 42 for chlorine, taste, and odor.) Both Documented | Up to 98.95% chlorine reduction claimed. Maker cites NSF/ANSI 42; no NSF listing found. Chloramine data not publicly documented. |
| Fluoride | Black Berkey Elements do not provide reliable long-term fluoride reduction. PF-2 add-on filters are required for consistent fluoride reduction, reducing fluoride up to 99.75%. PF-2 filters are compatible with both Black Berkey and Berkey Phoenix Elements ($103/pair, 1,000 gal capacity). | Fluoride reduction available via add-on filter (1,000 gal capacity). Waterdrop pages give different figures: 93%, 98%, and 99.9% initially. |
| Algae Toxins | Microcystin LR toxin reduced to non-detectable levels (>99.7%). ISO 17025 accredited lab. Downloadable lab report available. Documented | No algae toxin claims or testing data found publicly. |
Sources: Black Berkey data from independent lab reports by Envirotek Laboratories (EPA ID #NJ01298), County of Los Angeles ETL (CA State DHS certified), and BCS Laboratory (ISO 17025:2005, NELAP/TNI accredited). Waterdrop data from Waterdropfilter.com, the King Tank manual, and US retailer listings, checked October 28, 2026. Phoenix results are on the Phoenix lab results page. "Not publicly documented" indicates no downloadable third-party test report was found. It does not necessarily mean the filter does not reduce that contaminant.
Certification Summary
Berkey Phoenix Elements are certified to NSF/ANSI 42 and NSF/ANSI/CAN 372; Waterdrop's manual lists NSF/ANSI 372 certification by IAPMO R&T. The bigger gap is in published, broad-spectrum testing: both Berkey element lines are tested by independent accredited labs against 200+ contaminants, with downloadable reports. Waterdrop does not publish equivalent reports.
Media Recognition
Berkey's presence in third-party editorial coverage is documented and verifiable. Every citation on the Berkey Media Coverage page links directly to the original article.
Waterdrop's website does not display a media recognition section with links to independent editorial coverage of the King Tank. Independent reviews of the system exist on third-party sites but are not curated or documented by Waterdrop directly.
Feature Comparisons
Filtration Speed
Waterdrop does not publish a flow rate for the King Tank; one third-party reviewer measured about 4 gallons per hour, which would be in line with Berkey's ratings. Berkey rates Phoenix Elements at up to 4.2 gallons per hour per pair with a full upper chamber (max rating), and a Big Berkey with 2 Black Berkey Elements at up to about 3.5 gallons per hour with a full upper chamber. On any gravity filter, flow slows as the upper chamber empties and as the elements load up with sediment.
Fluoride Reduction
Black Berkey Elements do not provide reliable long-term fluoride reduction on their own. For consistent fluoride reduction, Berkey's PF-2 Fluoride and Arsenic Reduction filters are required, reducing fluoride up to 99.75%. PF-2 filters ($103/pair) are compatible with both Black Berkey Elements and Berkey Phoenix Elements, rated for 1,000 gallons per pair, and screw directly onto the bottom of each gravity element. Waterdrop also sells fluoride filter add-ons for the King Tank at a lower price ($56.99 per pair), rated for 1,000 gallons per pair. At about 1 gallon a day, the 1,000 gallon rating takes almost 3 years to reach, so the PF-2 one-year limit is what sets Berkey's replacement schedule.
System Size Options
Berkey offers multiple system sizes, from the 2.25-gallon Big Berkey up to the 6-gallon Crown, giving households of different sizes more flexibility. Waterdrop's King Tank is 2.25 gallons, and Waterdrop also sells a 1.5 gallon gravity model. If you need capacity beyond 2.25 gallons, Berkey is the only option between the two brands.
Spigot Design
The Waterdrop King Tank includes a metal sight-glass spigot as standard equipment, which allows real-time water level monitoring via a red float ball. Berkey systems ship with a plastic spigot. Metal spigots generally offer better durability and Waterdrop's design adds a functional convenience feature. Berkey does sell stainless steel spigot upgrades separately for buyers who prefer metal, and our lifetime warranty covers the plastic spigot that ships with the system.
Warranty
The Berkey manufacturer warranty covers chambers and lids for 1 year, Berkey Phoenix Elements for 1 year, Black Berkey Elements for 2 years (prorated), and PF-2 filters and accessories for 6 months. Systems bought from BigBerkeyWaterFilters.com also get our lifetime warranty on the stainless steel chambers, lid, the plastic spigot that ships with the system, and hardware. Waterdrop offers a 1-year warranty on manufacturing defects and a 30-day return window.
Long-Term Cost Comparison
Filter replacement economics matter more than system purchase price over a multi-year ownership window.
Berkey (Big Berkey, 2 Phoenix)
Phoenix pair rated 5,500 gal, no time limit: no replacement in 5 years (1,825 gal)
About 2 cents per gallon rated ($120/pair)
With PF-2 for fluoride ($103/pair yearly): about $782
Waterdrop King Tank
On the 6,000 gal rating alone: no replacement in 5 years (about $150)
On the maker's 6-month advice: 9 more carbon pairs at $78.99 (about $861)
Fluoride replacement pairs: $56.99 (1,000 gal)
Waterdrop's replacement filters cost less per pair, and its system costs less upfront. Over five years the answer depends on whether owners follow the gallon rating or the maker's 6-month advice: about $150 versus about $861 for Waterdrop, against about $267 for a Big Berkey with Phoenix Elements, which have no time limit. Cost also depends on what is being reduced: both Berkey element lines are tested against 200+ contaminants. Waterdrop's testing documentation focuses primarily on chlorine, taste, odor, and heavy metals, with no published data for PFAS or pharmaceuticals.
Frequently Asked Questions: Berkey vs. Waterdrop
Waterdrop and Berkey both offer gravity-fed stainless steel filtration systems. Waterdrop has a lower upfront price and a metal sight-glass spigot. Berkey Phoenix Elements are certified to NSF/ANSI 42 and NSF/ANSI/CAN 372, and both Berkey element lines are tested by independent accredited laboratories against 200+ contaminants, including PFAS (7 compounds for Phoenix, 9 for Black Berkey). For buyers who want documented broad-spectrum filtration data, Berkey provides more transparency. For buyers focused on chlorine reduction at a lower cost, Waterdrop is competitive.
We found no PFAS claim on Waterdrop's King Tank product page and no published lab report for PFAS. Berkey Phoenix Elements were tested on 7 PFAS compounds at 99.8%+ initial reduction, and Black Berkey Elements on 9 compounds including PFOA, PFOS, PFNA, PFBS, and PFHxS at >99.9% reduction, with PFOA reduced to below 2 ppt. Those reports are available for download at BigBerkey's test results page.
Waterdrop claims NSF/ANSI 42 and 372 for the King Tank. Its manual lists certification by IAPMO R&T to NSF/ANSI 372 for lead-free materials, and we found no NSF/ANSI 42 listing for it. The system does not hold NSF/ANSI 53, which would certify performance against health-effects contaminants like lead and VOCs; Berkey elements are not certified to NSF/ANSI 53 either.
Berkey Phoenix Elements are certified to NSF/ANSI 42 and NSF/ANSI/CAN 372, and both Berkey element lines are tested by independent accredited laboratories against 200+ contaminants, with downloadable results. Waterdrop's cited standards cover taste, odor, and materials safety but do not include the same breadth of independently documented contaminant reduction data.
The Waterdrop King Tank's carbon filters are rated for up to 6,000 gallons, and Waterdrop advises replacing them every 6 months. Berkey Phoenix Elements are rated for 5,500 gallons per pair and Black Berkey Elements for 6,000, with no time limit. The fluoride add-on filters for both brands are rated for 1,000 gallons per pair; Berkey's PF-2 also has a one-year limit, which sets the schedule at about 1 gallon a day.
No. Waterdrop explicitly states it is an independent brand with no affiliation with Berkey. Waterdrop does sell replacement filters marketed as compatible with Berkey systems, but the two companies have no corporate relationship. Berkey systems sold through BigBerkeyWaterFilters.com are genuine, and new Big and Royal systems come with Berkey Phoenix Elements or, while supplies last, Black Berkey Elements.
Waterdrop does not publish a flow rate for the King Tank; one third-party reviewer measured about 4 gallons per hour. Berkey rates Phoenix Elements at up to 4.2 gallons per hour per pair with a full upper chamber (max rating), and a Big Berkey with 2 Black Berkey Elements at up to about 3.5 gallons per hour with a full upper chamber.
Both the Berkey and Waterdrop King Tank use durable stainless steel housings with replaceable filter elements. Berkey has a 25+ year track record, and systems bought from BigBerkeyWaterFilters.com add our lifetime warranty on stainless chambers and hardware; Waterdrop offers a 1-year warranty. Waterdrop filters cost less per pair, but its 6-month replacement advice raises yearly cost at typical use. Both Berkey element lines are tested against 200+ contaminants with publicly available reports, which Waterdrop does not currently match.
Our Verdict
Waterdrop is a legitimate option for buyers whose primary goal is chlorine, taste, and odor reduction at a lower upfront price. It is a well-built stainless countertop system with a metal sight-glass spigot, and its housing is certified to NSF/ANSI 372 for lead-free materials. Where Berkey separates itself is documentation depth. Both Berkey element lines are tested by independent accredited laboratories against 200+ contaminants, including PFAS (7 compounds for Phoenix, 9 for Black Berkey, with PFOA brought to below 2 ppt). That level of testing transparency is not matched by Waterdrop's current public documentation. Buyers who want to know precisely what their filter is reducing, backed by published third-party lab data, are better served by Berkey. Buyers with a tighter budget who primarily want improved taste and chlorine reduction will find the Waterdrop King Tank a reasonable choice, and can ask Waterdrop for its test reports before purchasing.
Additional Resources
- Berkey Lab Test Results: downloadable PDFs from independent accredited laboratories
- Berkey Phoenix Elements Lab Results: Phoenix test data
- Berkey Media Coverage: verified third-party editorial coverage
- Shop Berkey Phoenix Elements: the replacement element
See Berkey's Full Test Results
Compare independently verified lab data for 200+ contaminants and explore the full system lineup.
Dan DeBaun
Dan is the owner and operator of Big Berkey Water Filters. Prior to Berkey, Dan was an asset manager for a major telecommunications company. He graduated from Rutgers with an undergraduate degree in industrial engineering, followed by an MBA in finance from Rutgers as well. Dan enjoys biohacking, exercising, meditation, beach life, and spending time with family and friends.
Trust the largest authorized US Berkey dealer on water filtration? Make us your Preferred Source on Google.
-
Out of stockOur most popular system. Serves 1 to 4 people.
Regular price From $267.00Regular priceUnit price / per$284.00Sale price From $267.00Out of stock -
Regular price From $308.00Regular priceUnit price / per
$326.00Sale price From $308.00Sale -
Fits every Berkey system. NSF/ANSI 42 and 372 certified.
Regular price $120.00Regular priceUnit price / perSale price $120.00 -
Adds fluoride and arsenic reduction to your Berkey.
Regular price $103.00Regular priceUnit price / perSale price $103.00



